Do it Yourself Storage Area Network (SAN)

| 3 Comments



Supermicro SANIf your IT department is being squeezed by the downturn in the economy but still needs to add let's say a storage area network (SAN) then why not do it yourself (DIY). Sure you could contact your favorite hardware vendor like Dell, HP, IBM etc., but when you compare the costs of an off the shelf product compared to the DIY project you'll realize big savings, in our case around 50%.

My company currently has a need for SAN. Based on our needs we decided to go with a 24 TB SATA in 4U form. Total cost for parts, taxes and shipping $9,500 Canadian. Comparable vendor systems start at around $30,000.

We generally buy Supermicro boards and chassis as they're good quality at a good price. Our operating system (OS) of choice is FreeBSD. Here's the basic specifications we used.

A 24 disk storage array consisting of the following hardware:


NOTES:

  1. Sufficient memory needs to be onboard for fsck of 20+TB, and large filesystems can consume a large amount of RAM or not work at all without it.  1GB RAM per 1TB storage is a common rule, so running 8GB is a lower limit, not an upper limit.

  2. We also need reliable GPT support for this size of an array, which is not there yet on many OSs.

  3. X7DWN+ is not listed on Supermicro's BSD compatibility matrix, but people report OK use under Free BSD 7.0 REL

  4. A useful discussion about compatible generic memory for the Areca controller

  5. Areca manuals, benchmarks, firmwares etc.

  6. Drive compatibility with the RAID controller needs to be established. For compatible Western Digital drives this requires adjusting the TLER values in each drive's bios prior to using it in the RAID array. Note the DOS utility rewrites the BIOS of all attached drives, so this should only be done an a system dedicated to this task. Other non-RAID certified drives may need similar adjustments.

  7. Western Digital reports the 1TB GP as compatible with the Areca.

  8. As of 12 November 2008, only a handful of 1TB drives are certified by Areca and several common ones are explicitly NOT compatible. In the Western Digital line only the WD RE2 GP RAID Edition 1TB is certifed, with SAS controller firmware V1.45 80915 or later. Unfortunately such RAID-certified drives are nearly double the cost of non-RAID variants.

  9. Western Digital Green Power (WD GP) drives are only 5400 RPM but reports suggest that differences in read/write performance between hard drive brands becomes less important as more drives are added to the array.

  10. A test report of an Areca 1680-type SAS controller

  11. This 2GB memory module reported to be compatible with a 1680 controller. Worth getting.

  12. Without the battery backup the Areca cards turn off write-caching completely to help prevent data loss.


OTHER NOTE:

  1. use http://www.shopbot.ca/ to find the lowest price on gear above for price matching purposes. Some items in the SAN parts list are already linked to shopbot.

3 Comments

Thanks for sharing this info Marc. I'm curious why you didn't use Open Solaris for this given ZFS and DTrace. I would have thought ZFS would be particularly useful for a SAN.

We generally use FreeBSD but have not decided 100% on the OS as of yet. We may yet use Open Solaris.

I think most of the value in storage area network solutions these days is in the software, not the hardware. Most of the big name players are moving or already using industry standard hardware and the magic is in their software.

Justin Lofton
VP of Engineering
Tredent Data Systems, Inc.
Storage Area Networking Experts

Leave a comment - Sign in with SpaceRef, Google, Yahoo or OpenID accounts

Recent Blog Entries

What if Twitter was Down for Several Days? Perhaps it's Time for a new Internet Protocol
Anil Dash has an opinion piece today on CNN which basically says don't let a service like Twitter or Facebook…
Using Social Media Tools Like Twitter to add Value to Advertisers Campaigns
SpaceRef has recently started using Twitter as an additional marketing tool as part of our advertisers campaigns. We don't spam…
Apple 12″ PowerBook G4 Meet Yellow Dog Linux
I hate it when a perfectly good computer just sits around doing nothing. In this case it's my old Apple…
New Media Hearings - CRTC Should Once Again Do Nothing
Ten years ago I testified at the Canadian Radio-television Telecommunications Commission's (CRTC) New Media hearings in Ottawa and argued that…
Analysis - Twitter's Business Model & Sector Sentiment
I joined Twitter on May 8, 2007 on the advice of my business partner at @SpaceRef @KeithCowing. Not too long…
What Alternative Space News Sources Including Blogs, Social Networking Sites do you Use?
There are many good space news sources available, they include SpaceRef, Space.com, NASA Watch, The Space Review, Spaceflight Now etc.…